English Guernsey Cattle Society 
 
 News
 
 History
 
 Herd of the Month
 
 Shows
 
 A2 Milk
 
 Breeding
 
 Guernsey Business
 Cheese
 Beef
 Ice Cream
 Herd Sales
 Semen Sales
 
 Animal Information
 
 Links
 
 Membership & Registration
 
 Council Members & Contacts
Search

Shows Last Updated: Nov 25, 2008 - 10:00:12 AM


The Bath and West 2008 Judge's Report
By Andrew Waters
Jun 2, 2008 - 3:10:44 PM

Email this article
 Printer friendly page
 Discuss this story
 Page Hits: 28

Well this year’s show will certainly be remembered for some time to come with a double Interbreed success for the Guernseys and the flash floods that hit the area on the Thursday evening.

Heifer in Calf.

This class was led by a very powerful and well balanced Tiresford Pedro heifer from Blacknor ahead of the very stylish and correct Yogibear heifer from Kenvin.  Third was Bickfield with a Tiresford Atlantic heifer who was not quite so correct over the rump or mammary as my first two.  My fourth and fifth placed animals although very commendable lacked a little stature and body width on the day.

Cow in Calf.

First in this class was Kenvin Enticers Lynne who after having had 8 calves was still showing fantastic balance, is beautifully correct and displaying great udder attachment and teat placement.  Second was a Tiresford Atlantic from Chettle who displayed great dairyness with good capacity and stature but not quite so correct in the udder traits and tailhead.  Third and fourth didn’t have the stature or capacity of the first two and also not quite so correct in the udder.

Heifer in Milk.

The milky, stylish Pedro heifer from Blacknor got the nod ahead of a very nice correct Silverado from Kenvin who on the day was a little short of milk.

Junior Cow in Milk.

The largest class of the day was led by two Hawks from Bickfield the winner displaying slightly more openness of rib and capacity and also more correct throughout the udder than my second, third was a very good Sonny Boy from Graylands who was nicely balanced with a correct udder but lacked a little capacity.  Again my lower placings didn’t quite have the stature, balance or capacity of my first two who were outstanding in this class.

Intermediate Cow in Milk.

Cracker Duchess by Shalford Teak led this class, she displayed superb body capacity, width and depth of rib combining to make a very powerful cow with a high and wide rear udder which was also well attached in the fore.  She walked well on good legs and feet and was well balanced. This capacity and blending/balance gave her the edge over an Ambionic from Bickfield who was a lovely dairy cow with fine bone and had the advantage in the legs and feet over the third placed Kingwell cow by Stroxworthy Magicans Fancy who had the advantage over the forth placed Graylands by Iceman in body depth and correctness of udder.

Senior cow in Milk.

Bickfield Dot 56 by S.Park Talisman who had the advantage in length and depth of body, hard top and good udder traits, second was Greensfield with a Shalford Rumbustious who was nice and dairy, which had the advantage over third placed Brymor Danielle 21 by Glacier from Chettle in more correct udder traits.

Group of Three.

First and clear winners of this class was the group from Bickfield.

They were superbly matched in every department and one of the best groups I have ever judged.  I even tipped them for glory the following day and they duly obligied!  Congratulations to Maurice, May, Kim and Neil on a great achievement.

Reserve Group went to Chettle who had some great individuals but not the balance and evenness of the winners.

Pairs.

This again was won by the beautifully balanced pair of Hawks from Bickfield with the Pedros from Chettle in reserve.

Championship.

I tapped out Cracker Duchess as a deserved Champion. She displayed a lot of great qualities. Her power, width, correctness and super udder gave her the advantage over the rest of the line up.  Again congratulations to Ian on taking the Interbreed dairy title later in the day.  This is a fantastic achievement for Ian and the breed.

Reserve Champion went to Bickfield Valerie 20, who displayed similar qualities to the champion with her balance and capacity.

Hon Mention went to Kenvin Enticers Lynne who after 8 calves was in such super form.

Bookmark and Share

Comments

Ian Crouch
05 Jun 2008, 04:12
It is a shame that the Judge did not check his facts before posting his report,he twice mentions Blacknor in his report, the Blacknor herd was purchased by Chettle Guernsey Cream( Ian Crouch and his unmentionable partner)in October 2007
Blacknor Lucy 70(second in In Calf class), is sired by Magdalen Gladiator and not Tiresford Atlantic as stated.
Since 1980 when the St Ivel trophy,for the Inter Breed Champion was introduced, it has been won by Holstein/Freisian on 19 occasions, by Aryshires on 6 occasions, by the Jerseys on 2 occasions,and for the first time by the Guernseys.
Given that numbers were restricted by Blue Tongue controls, the Guernsey breed should be planning for next year and trying to repeat the feat.
We are!
Kim Sales
11 Jun 2008, 17:22
As chair of the Judges Standing Committee, I feel I must comment in support of Judge, Andrew Waters.

The mistake in the cow in calf class was an easy one to make as I'm sure Andrew referred to the catalogue when making his report. The animal entered in the catalogue was sired by Atlantic. A substitution had been made by Chettle Guernsey Cream and a different animal was forward in the class. Andrew could only go by what was printed in the catalogue.

As to the reference to animals being from Blacknor, these cows carry the Blacknor prefix, so are technically Blacknor cows.

The situation at Chettle can seem a little confusing to an outsider as the cattle have several prefixes and two different owners.

Having said that, the fact that it was the first time that a guernsey has won the St. Ivel Trophy, it is a tremendous achievement and one that hopefully will be repeated in the near future.
Ian Crouch
14 Jun 2008, 03:11
Kim,
The substitution was made before the catalogue was printed,and after the Livestock Office insisted that the "schedule" was correct, this despite our understanding that the Dry cow class was for all ages.

John Sansom (Blacknor)retired from Dairy Farming on 1st October 2007 and all animals born after that date have been registered as Cracker or Chiddingstone.
Chettle Guernsey Cream is the partnership name and pays the "headage" payment through NMR on a monthly DD,although it is becoming more difficult to justify this expense given the lack of services and information from EGCS.
5 of the 6 animals at B&W were bred at Chettle,are you suggesting that no purchased animals should be shown? That would be a pity as we have 2 Bickfield heifers for the Autumn shows.
Finally why was an"outsider" appointed to judge the major summer show?













*Name:
Email:
Notify me about new comments on this page
Hide my email
*Text:
Security Image:

Visual CAPTCHA


 

Copyright 1998-2008 English Guernsey Cattle Society
Scotsbridge House, Scots Hill, Rickmansworth, Herts. United Kingdom Tel 44-1923-695-204 Fax 44-1923-695-215. Registered in England No. 225962

Top of Page

Latest Headlines
News
Christmas 2008 Guernsey News
Classified Advertisements - For Sale and Wants
In Memory of Belinda
History
The World's Largest Guernsey Cow
Usefulness Of The Old Scrapbook?
The Great Guernsey Cow Give-Away
Herd of the Month
The Skeel Herd -- June Herd of the Month
The St. Senara Herd
The Carne Herd
Shows
South West Dairy Show 2008
South West Guernsey Cattle Breeders Association 2008 Stockjudging Competition
South West All Breeds Calf Show - 2008
A2 Milk
Suppliers of Guernsey Milk
Mount Prosperous Herd Tested for A2 Status
New Zealand Clarifies Research on A2 Milk
Breeding
Guernseys improve on all measures
Lies, and Statistics
Has the GGBP been a success?
Guernsey Business
Coopers Court Guernseys to 2,800 Guineas
Dispersal of the Golden Valley Herd - Peter Burton
The Bickfield Draft Sale Results - March 29 2008
Animal Information
Guernsey Animal Information
Top Males by GMI
Top Females by GMI
Links
Gold Top Milk -- Exclusively Channel Islands Milk
Links Library
Current Links Worth Visiting
Membership & Registration
EGCS E-Mail Mailing List
Report on the 2008 Annual General Meeting
Join The Guernsey Cattle Society - Now Online
Council Members & Contacts
EGCS Council Members 2008-2009